Writing a Proof of Evidence

Someone who is to be a witness at a court or tribunal writes down everything they can remember. This is called a Proof of Evidence. Usually a lawyer acting for the party which will (or may) be calling the witness drafts a Witness Statement for the witness from the witness's Proof of Evidence.

In the case of a Land Registry Application - rather than court or tribunal proceedings - the document drafted from the witness's Proof of Evidence is called a Statement of Truth or a Statutory Declaration, rather than a Witness Statement, but in this article for brevity I use the phrase "Witness Statement" to cover either.

A Witness Statement is in a particular format as required by the court/tribunal/Land Registry rules and the lawyer will leave out of the Witness Statement material which is not relevant to the Application or litigation (in any court/tribunal case some things will turn out to be in dispute and some will turn out not to be in dispute - only the material in the Proof of Evidence relevant to the issues in dispute will be in the Witness Statement which is used in the court/tribunal). For this reason it is helpful if a witness can provide a Proof of Evidence as a Word document as well as a signed copy.           


When writing your Proof of Evidence:-


1. Start with:
  • Your full name 
  • full address including Postcode
  • occupation

2. Write down everything you remember which might be relevant to the case. If in doubt whether something is relevant, include it anyway (if it turns out not to be relevant the lawyer drafting your witness statement can always omit it from the Witness Statement when that is drafted).


3. Use short paragraphs and number the paragraphs  


4. Your Proof of Evidence contains what you yourself remember. You cannot have a joint Proof of Evidence with someone else. Everyone who will (or may) be giving evidence has to provide their own separate Proof of Evidence.


5. Your Proof of Evidence contains what you yourself remember seeing/hearing. You must make clear how you know things. So don't just say, for example:

"John Smith built the wall in April 2010."

Rather say 

"I was living next door at the time and I remember seeing John Smith himself building the wall in April 2010."

or

"The wall went up in April 2010. I did not actually see the work being done because at that time I normally left for work at about 7.00 am and didn't get back until about 6.30 pm but, over a period of a week or so, I noticed each day that more of the wall had been built. I don't know whether John Smith built it with his own hands or whether he got builders to do it."

or 
"The wall went up in April 2010. I did not actually see the work being done because at that time I normally left for work at about 7.00 am and didn't get back until about 6.30 pm but, over a period of a week or so, I noticed each day that more of the wall had been built. At the time I didn't know whether John Smith had built it with his own hands or whether he got builders to do it, but a few months later I got speaking to him one day when we were both putting our recycling bins out and he told me that he had built it all himself."   

or 
"The wall went up in April 2010. I did not actually see the work being done because at that time I normally left for work at about 7.00 am and didn't get back until about 6.30 pm but, over a period of a week or so, I noticed each day that more of the wall had been built. At the time I didn't know whether John Smith had built it with his own hands or whether he got builders to do it, but now that this current dispute has arisen I have asked John Smith and he has told me that he built the wall himself."   

or
"I moved into the area in June 2016 so I have no personal knowledge of events before then but I have recently obtained a Street View image from Google dated 2013 (Exhibit JJS2) and from this I can see that there was a wall in position at that time."  


so that it is clear how you know what you are saying.


6, You can give your overall impression of a state of affairs - e.g. "John Smith appeared to be drunk" but if you can remember specific details which gave you that impression - e.g. "He had difficulty keeping his balance when walking and his speech was slurred" that should be included.


7. Sometimes your impression of a state of affairs may be the result of a number of incidents over a period of time. For example you might have gained the impression that someone owned, or at least occupied, a piece of land because, over the years you (a) saw them cultivating the land, (b) you saw them locking a gate opening onto the land, (c) you asked them if they would mind if you walked your dog on their land and they said Yes, or they said No, but they didn't say it was nothing to do with them or that you would have to ask someone else. If so then you should give this information. 


8. Write what you remember in chronological order so far as possible. The sequence of events can be important.



9. Give dates for everything as best you can remember. You may know the exact date of something if it happened to coincide with a memorable event such as your birthday, or you may have documents which help you remember – for example in the case of a meeting you might have a dated note of what was discussed at the meeting, or you may have a letter or email in which the date of the meeting was arranged, or a letter or email written soon after as a consequence of the meeting. Or you may be able to remember only approximately - e.g. “June 2011”, “just before Christmas 2011” “in the summer of 2008” “in around 2007 or 2008” etc.
 

10. Give names if you know them. If you don’t know a name, say so. So don’t just write “I was told that…” say “John Smith told me that…” or, if you cannot remember who told you something, make that clear – “Someone – I cannot now remember who – told me that…” “Someone at the office – I cannot now remember who – told me that…” Someone at the office – I think it was Paul Jones but it could have been someone else - told me that…” etc.

 

11. You should make a PDF copy of every relevant photograph you have taken and give it a filename with your initials and a number – e.g. if you are John James Smith, give the first photo a filename of JJS1, JJS2 for the second etc. Then say in your Proof of Evidence that you took the photo and when, and what it is a photo of - e.g. "I refer to Exhibit JJS1 which is a photo I took of the garden on 15/9/2016". If there is a specific point you want to make about what the photo shows, make the point, but you should always say when you took every relevant photo even if you feel that the photo speaks for itself so that no further comment needs to be made about that particular photo. If you need to exhibit a marked copy of a photo to point something out, always make a PDF copy and mark up the copy, keeping the original safe and separate. When you mark up a copy of a photo, give the marked copy one PDF name – e.g. JJS4 and provide an unmarked PDF copy as well – e.g. JJS3. If you didn't actually press the camera button but you still took the photo in the sense that you asked someone else to take it, and were present when they took it, make that clear. 


12. If you have relevant photos which you didn't take and the person who took them is not going to be a witness you should say what you know about the photo - e.g. "When my mother died in 2005 I inherited a number of photos one of which is Exhibit JJS5. I recognise the girl in the picture as my sister Lucy, born in 1960, and she looks about 10 years old in the photo so I know that this photo, which shows the garden wall in dispute in this case, was taken about 1970.


13. If you refer to a photo which is in the report of an expert witness (e.g. surveyor) you can identify it using the reference in the report - e.g. "I refer to photograph 18 in Appendix A of the report of Mr Hooper dated 23/5/2015..." and you don't need to make an Exhibit (unless, of course, you need to create a PDF copy to mark up to show some point - see paragraph 9  above)


14. If you have a relevant video or audio recording, say when and where you took/recorded it and what it shows/records.


15. You should make PDF copies of other key documents that you refer to, naming them with Exhibit numbers e.g. JJS6, JJS7, JJS8 etc. 


16. If the case involves a lot of correspondence -  letters and emails (or a lot of, say, bank transactions shown on bank statements) then you do not need to create Exhibits for them all and you can just refer to items by date (or date and time in the case of emails) and sender/recipient name - e.g. "The reason why I sent the email to Phillip Jones at 15.20 on 13/8/2014 was..."  If there could be any doubt about what letter you are referring to - e.g. if you received a letter which bears no date - you should create a PDF copy and refer to that - e.g. "I refer to Exhibit JJS9 which is an undated letter I received in response..." but generally you do not need to create Exhibits where there is a lot of correspondence. If it turns out that, exceptionally, Exhibits are required (e.g. because it is not the kind of proceedings where there will be an agreed trial bundle) then the lawyer settling the witness statement should ask you to do this.      
              

17. End your Proof of Evidence by saying "I am willing to attend court/tribunal to give evidence if necessary".


18. Some people misunderstand what a Proof of Evidence is and think it is like giving a job reference but this is a mistake. If you are giving someone a job reference you are often (depending on the type of reference) recommending someone as well as providing basic information about them. But a Proof of Evidence just gives the complete unbiased picture to the best of your knowledge. Another difference between a Proof of Evidence and something like a job reference is that job references tend to be fairly short and give general impressions - the person to whom the reference is sent can always ring up the person giving the reference and ask for more details. But a Proof of Evidence should contain all the detailed information that you can remember. You can give general impressions but you should also give the detailed information on which your general impression is based. If all you can remember is a general impression then make this clear - e.g. "my memory is that he was very hard working but it is so long ago that I cannot remember what specifically gave me that impression" .But if you can remember specific details  then you should give all the details you can remember - e.g. "I remember that he was very hard working. For instance on one occasion, in 2006 I think, he... I also remember that...".


Disclaimer

This information page is designed to be used only by clients of John Antell who have entered into an agreement for the provision of legal services. The information in it is necessarily of a general nature and is intended to be used only in conjunction with specific advice to the individual client about the individual case. This information page should not be used by, or relied on, by anyone else.

The information on this page about specific computer techniques is provided for information purposes only. Every reasonable effort has been made to ensure that the information is accurate and up to date at the time it was written but no responsibility for its accuracy, or for any consequences of relying on it, is assumed by me. You should satisfy yourself, before using any of the techniques, software or services described, that the techniques are appropriate for your purposes and that the software or service is reliable.


This page was lasted updated in April 2017 Disclaimer